Are Appeals to Expert Consensus Fallacious?

It is (in my experience online) often claimed that appeal to expert consensus on a topic is an instance of the ad populum or "appeal to the masses" informal fallacy. Consider this example of interlocutors we can call A and B for convenience' sake. A: Why do you believe in anthropogenic climate change? B: Well, … Continue reading Are Appeals to Expert Consensus Fallacious?

Review of Heather: “Empires and Barbarians”

Micah Edvenson, review of Empires and Barbarians: The Fall of Rome and the Birth of Europe, by Peter Heather, Oxford University Press, 2009. Peter Heather's 2009 book "Empires and Barbarians" is a sprawling and impressive contribution to the study of Late Antiquity/The Early Middle Ages. The following is as if now, not a comprehensive summary … Continue reading Review of Heather: “Empires and Barbarians”

Wittgenstein on whether “Thinking is a mental process”

This post like my last one is content from a seminar assignment. I was prompted to answer whether Wittgenstein would agree with the claim that "thinking is a mental process" in roughly 500 words. Here is my take on the matter, which I find useful in that I attempt to clarify why some readings of … Continue reading Wittgenstein on whether “Thinking is a mental process”

Fragmentary Questions and Comments from My First Encounter with Wittgenstein’s “Philosophical Investigations”

I would be remiss in not giving some preliminary context for the present post, so here goes. This past semester at University I took an advanced undergraduate seminar on Ludwig Wittgenstein's "Philosophical Investigations" and it was, if nothing else, a formative philosophical experience. This was not only my first formal interaction with Wittgenstein's work, but … Continue reading Fragmentary Questions and Comments from My First Encounter with Wittgenstein’s “Philosophical Investigations”

My Key Philosophical Views

In this post I will answer some questions from the PhilPapers surveys in order to document some of my key philosophical positions and positions on a few issues I find important or interesting. This will not be exhaustive, I will cover the essentials and a handful of other things for now, although eventually I would … Continue reading My Key Philosophical Views